Wednesday, March 16, 2016

Inquiring, not telling!

The questions are: 

On the ‘teller’/Inquiry spectrum I am …

To be successful Inquiry needs to be ...

What are the stages of Inquiry in the Australian Curriculum: HASS?

What are the advantages for learning of the Inquiry approach?

What are some of the issues to keep in mind when planning an inquiry approach?

How can it be said that there is far too much emphasis on inquiry approaches in the classroom?

Does Inquiry significantly improve learning?

Why can it be said that Inquiry has the potential to be abused in the classroom?

Why would a teacher not use inquiry methodology?


Related sites to HumsRus blog 
Spatialworlds
Australian Curriculum Portal
GeogSpace
AC History Units
Geogaction
DECD Learning Resources for Australian Curriculum
DECD Achievement Standards Charts 
Australian Geography Teachers' Association website

Geography Teachers Association of South Australia
History Teachers Association of South Australia
History Teachers Association of Australia

Scoop.it 



 Teacher support for inquiry

In viewing numerous classroom scenarios on inquiry, we see the principle of inductive reasoning at the center of the teacher’s approach. Students begin with a source – a cup or a dress and their thinking and reasoning is guided to begin firstly with the particular and then branching out to the more general.

Inductive reasoning means restricting oneself to sources and then formulating statements based on them. Sources are used as a starting point to inquiry, - further research will hopefully result from this activity. The kind of research the students will be carrying out will be inductive as they will be establishing facts directly referred to by the sources and they will be making inferences from the sources they are working with and researching further.

Principle number 1. Start with the particular, move out to the general. Otherwise the opposite of this is deductive reasoning which consists in passing from the ‘the universal’ to ‘the particular’. It is less likely that a primary school student will know how to draw conclusions from certain general truths.

The second principle that underpins this type of inquiry is active, student centred learning – but well supported and scaffolded by the teacher. It’s what Webster calls “light assistance”. Pedagogically speaking the approach is robust – it sits very much within a context of social constructivism. The interaction between you and the student is crucial even though you may think this approach is all about handing over responsibility for learning to the student. Yes, that’s partly true. Good inquiry methodology results in the interaction between adult and student guiding student thinking (From Sage on the Stage to Guide on the Side). Teachers have a vital role to play developing effective inquiry learning which includes initiating good questions to research and to analyse and to come up with reasoned meaningful conclusions. By promoting active learning – that is not just doing but thinking-- in classrooms the learning outcomes are more likely to become intellectually embedded says Hutchings, “what we discover, we retain”

The third principle underpinning inquiry learning is the use of open ended questioning, resulting in deep levels of engagement with problems that are likely to be multifaceted and complex. Its nature is exploratory (Hutchings, 2007). Hutchings says that the core of inquiry is the question and it is in the formulation and ‘or the analysis of that question that the important initial intellectual activity takes place. Philosophically it is a Socratic based activity - Socratic perception that our knowledge is formed by questions.

Students participate in acts of discovery, grappling with different ways of looking at ideas and issues and thinking creatively about problems that do not necessarily have simple answers.

The 'Instructional Strategies online' site succinctly sums up inquiry methodology when it says:

Using inquiry, students become actively involved in the learning process as they:

* act upon their curiosity and interests;
* develop questions;
* think their way through controversies or dilemmas;
* look at problems analytically;
* inquire into their preconceptions and what they already know;
* develop, clarify, and test hypotheses; and,
* draw inferences and generate possible solutions.

Wednesday, March 2, 2016

Population and migration


Image above: The age-sex structure for Australia and New Zealand.


Related sites to HumsRus blog
Spatialworlds
Australian Curriculum Portal
Geogaction
DECD Learning Resources for Australian Curriculum
DECD Achievement Standards Charts 
Australian Geography Teachers' Association website

Geography Teachers Association of South Australia
History Teachers Association of South Australia
History Teachers Association of Australia 

Scoop.it 



To support Module 1 work

Hi all
Great to meet you all at Mawson Lakes and Magill during out tutes. As mentioned, here is the posting to support our discussions on migration. Have a good look at these sites and I am sure you will be informed and even surprised by what they tell you about migration and population around the world. 

Remember to do the readings, double entry journal and activities as outlined on the Uni SA site for Module 1. 

*  Here is the link to the Australian National Maritime Museum migration stories (link did not work on Uni SA site).

**  Assignment 1 instructions/guide presentation

*** Tutorial presentation on history 

Some sites on population to check out

* Migration flows
This interactive migration map allows you to see for every country in the world either the top ten providing countries of lifetime migrants or the top ten receiving countries of lifetime migrants. On top of that, when you let your mouse hover over a country, you can see the total population, the GDP per capita, the HIV and Tuberculosis prevalence and the death rate of children under five.






Population pyramids

This interactive site enables you to see the age-sex pyramids for every country in the world. A great resource for comparison across the globe and awareness of diversity in age-sex structures between countries. The pyramids raise many question as to why they are the shape they are. The pyramids also go back in time and project forward - fascinating.









* World population clock


The Poodwaddle clock

* World population data interactive map from the Population Reference Bureau. This site provides excellent data updates in tabular form, as well as a user friendly interactive data map for every region and country in the world.




Monday, February 29, 2016

Australian Curriculum and HaSS



Image above: Cultural differences.


Related sites to Humsteach blog
Spatialworlds
Australian Curriculum Portal
Geogaction
DECD Learning Resources for Australian Curriculum
DECD Achievement Standards Charts 
Australian Geography Teachers' Association website

Geography Teachers Association of South Australia
History Teachers Association of South Australia
History Teachers Association of Australia 

Scoop.it 


Uni SA website and course details

Tutorial presentation

You think what?

"A curriculum is not value-free, as values and attitudes cannot be divorced from content."
The Shape of the Australian Curriculum: Geography January 2011

HASS subjects and their teaching is not value free. It is almost impossible not to be political in some way when discussing HASS topics.

As Robert Butler was quoted as saying in the Economist in 2010:

“It is getting harder and harder in conversation to raise one or other of the most basic subjects in geography—agriculture, glaciation, rivers and population—without a flicker of panic crossing the other person’s face. You are no longer talking about a neutral subject.”


HASS has the potential to be relevant, dynamic and challenging for students in the classroom through providing the opportunity to develop a political frame around what is taught. How can we teach about water, population, migration and climate change for example without challenging students to place the discussion in a political context – that is, what do you believe is right and what are the justice and ethical beliefs that guide ones opinion on an issue.



Here are two excellent classroom polling tools to have a look at and use to get discussion started.


* Straw Poll

What are your responses to the following following questions re: HASS 



  • Click on the URL's below and select your response.  

What subject of HASS do you like best?
http://strawpoll.me/6943450

Did you like Society and Environment at school?
https://strawpoll.me/6943458

Are you looking forward to teaching HASS?
http://strawpoll.me/6943465

Do you enjoy discussing issues?


* Poll everywhere

A digital tool that is a wonderful way to get students involved (all students, not just the vocal and uninhibited) in discussion of a contestable nature is Poll Everywhere. The brilliant aspect of this program is that it is easy to use, is anonymous and inclusive of all, can be used and developed in real time in the classroom and provides instant feedback (graphs, word walls etc). The program gives all students a voice so that they can express their opinion without ridicule or embarrassment. The resulting graphs and graphics provide data for class research and discussion and can be archived for comparison over time presentations. As a tool it is a great interactive way to involve the geography class in some high order thinking and discussion. 
The brief video on the Poll Everywhere Home page gives an introduction to this free digital tool which can be used not only in the geography classroom but also with teachers in their professional learning in geography. Here is a Poll Everywhere document I recently used with a group of teachers working on the concepts in history and geography. All they had to do was type the URL http://www.pollev.com and start submitting their response to the questions in the document by using the codes (each code is unique and can be used only once specifically for the question - called a poll) generated by the teacher/facilitator of the question. Poll Everywhere is a great way to get discussion started in any gathering.  It is certainly worth the 30 minutes to get acquainted with the tool and make the learning more interactive for participants and create some inclusive and comprehensive data for contestable discussions.



PollEverywhere responses

Go to PollEv.com/mal2013

or Text MAL2013 to +61 429 883 481


Why do we study HASS?


Can you list some HASS issues?

Is there any one issue that really interests/enthuses you?

Do you have any concerns about this class and how you may proceed/succeed?

Do you have any questions re: HASS before we continue?



TodaysMeet



Check this tool out and think about how you could use it in the classrtoom and
how we could use it in our tutorial. If you have already used it, be prepated to share yot thoughts.

Why is Humaniites so important?





How does a Humanities education help us to make sense of these two images?

Related sites to Humsteach blog
Spatialworlds
Australian Curriculum Portal
Geogaction
DECD Learning Resources for Australian Curriculum
Australian Geography Teachers' Association website

Geography Teachers Association of South Australia
History Teachers Association of South Australia
History Teachers Association of Australia

Scoop.it 





Welcome to the HASS  and I am thrilled that you will be having the opportunity to think HASS over the coming months. I look forward to work with you during the semester. 

The purpose of this blog is to supplement the work we do each week during the course. The posting will be brief and will be a mixture of thinkpieces for you to respond to and resources (websites, articles and books) that will augment our weekly topics. It would be great if you used the facility on the blog to be notified when a posting is published.

 

I obviously see that HASS is an incredibly important part of the curriculum and I thought you may be interested in this blog I recently posted - it makes an argument for the importance of the humanities in the curriculum.


THE THREAT OF FOCUSSING ON UTILITARIAN EDUCATION

With today’s global competition, there is increasing concern about the nature and quality of education– should it be primarily practical and utilitarian and equipping students to be competitive in the workforce or should it rather be a liberal education with broad ideas and values to prepare a well-rounded student with the capacity to be fully functional democratic citizens, prepared for life in contemporary society? For students to be successful in today’s global economy, it should be seen that utilitarian and liberal education need to be tightly coupled, and that students’ academic, developmental, interpersonal and experiential lives are entwined. Schools should move towards developing transformational learning for students and not just focus on providing knowledge and understandings based on employability. Such questioning of the utilitarian trend in education around the world is critical when we consider the decrease in curriculum time for humanities in schools and the significant drop off in the number of students studying geography in particular in the senior school in Australia and around the world.

Transformational learning means that the “whole student” has to develop so as to prepare him or her as a thinker and citizen for a challenging world; to question and affirm or change what she or he believes; and come to a greater understanding of the complex questions of his or her own life and the lives of others than they otherwise would. By attending to both leads to transformational learning and the development of the whole person into a flourishing individual and citizen.”

Traditionally in our school system the humanities’ (history, geography, studies of society etc) have developed those capacities referred to as liberal education. Ironically, it was the liberal subjects that dominated early education! In the present economic and educational environment the humanities in the senior school are being devalued and squeezed out of the curriculum in face of utilitarian demands. In Australia the humanities is declining in schools in terms of numbers, prestige and general influence. Many young people now leave school with a scant knowledge of history, geography and our society in general (law, government etc). The impact is particularly serious in the senior secondary year that provides a sophisticated understanding of the humanities for young people. The utilitarian demands on a young person when choosing subjects has resulted in significant reduction of the perceived ‘non employment direct’ subjects such as history, geography etc (in fact these subjects do have significant and much needed career pathways but often not seen as direct and thus not promoted as getting a student a job). As this blog has highlighted and discussed over the past 4 years, the opportunities in the spatial industry is enormous and subjects such as geography and history have an important role to play in developing student knowledge, skills and capacities in-line with the needs of that industry.

Australians hold what appear to be conflicting aspirational and practical notions of the purposes and value of a schooling. Economists and corporate leaders refer to this function of education as the development of human capital.
“…education is more than preparing for a job; it should be for acquiring the knowledge, skills, competencies, values, dispositions and capacities for many life roles in a world of inevitable change and that this is ultimately the more “practical” preparation for life.”
Anecdotally the trend away from the liberal humanities in school education, towards the demands of a utilitarian education, in particular in senior secondary, is common throughout the western world and similar OECD countries to Australia. There is a need to get quantitative and substantiated data on the trend away from the humanities and to research what other countries are doing to arrest the trend away from the humanities as highly respected (in number and prestige) subjects in schools. Those involved in humanities education consider that the trend away from the humanities towards utilitarian education in our schools (and universities) is undermining and threatening the development of a ‘well-rounded, thinking, socially analytical young citizen ready for the demands of the 21st Century globalised world.
Here are two really interesting articles from the UK re: importance of geography and diminishing numbers. Seems that the drift to utilitarian education is happening everywhere. 

1. "Without geography, the world would be a mystery to us"
Geography is the subject that contributes more than any other to young people’s knowledge of the world, writes David Lambert.

2. "History and geography 'diminishing' in schools", says head
Subjects such as English, history and geography are being marginalised as schools ditch academic rigour in favour of “accessibility”, according to a leading headmistress.

The irony is that humanities subjects do have a vocational 'purpose'. The humanities subjects develop the highly sought after employability skills of literacy, teamwork, decision making, problem solving, interpersonal skills etc. For example, geography is a great humanities subject for young people to do as citizens now and in the future and is a subject with increasing vocational opportunities in the branches of geography (climatology, economic analysis, planning, environmental management, disaster mitigation etc etc) and the related areas of the spatial industry. Geography is also a subject which goes somewhere in the world of employment. There is a lot of work to be done with subject counselors, vocational consultants, parents and the community to get the message across that geography and all the knowledge, skills and capacities it develops in young people is and should be promoted as a learning area with great (and increasing)

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

Critical Internet Literacy





Images above: A castle on a stack? The power to manipulate images

Related links
Geogsplace
Socialsense
Thebarton Senior College Moodle

Spatialworlds
Geographical thinking Scoop.it  
Spatial literacy Scoop.it  
History and geography Scoop.it

Email contact:
manning@chariot.net.au

Critical Internet Literacy


Recently at our faculty meetings we discussed the issue of Critical Internet Literacy.  This posting provides some information on assessing the validity of online resources and a range of bogus sites that have been created to peddle nonsense or falsity on purpose. As students are using Internet sources more and more, it is imperative that students develop critical literacy to determine the veracity of any site, regardless of its professional appearance. In fact, the technological and economic ease anyone can now develop a really professional and seemingly official site makes Critical Internet Literacy more important than ever.

Evaluating a site for veracity

The attached article suggests the following tips to avoid being ‘conned’ by ‘suss’ internet sites:
  •  Check for additional sources before you share anything
  •  Learn which websites not to trust
  •  Unfollow any websites that lies to you
  •  Use common sense.


A more detailed listing involves examining the site for:


1. Accuracy (Is the information reliable? Are the links accurate? Sources cited? Information believable?)
2. Authority (Who is the author of the site? What are his/her qualifications? Is the site sponsored by an organization? Is the organization reputable or legitimate?)
3. Objectivity (Does the information reveal a bias? What is the point of view of the author? Is the information trying to sway you? Do the links also reflect a bias?)
4. Currency (When was the site last updated? Is the information kept up to date? Is the publication date indicated? Are the links up to date?)
5. Coverage (How is the information presented? Heavy use of graphics, text, statistics? Topic coverage cursory or in-depth?) 

Here are some even more detailed questions to check out a site are:


1. The source of the page
*Who wrote the page?
*Can you contact him or her?
*Does he/she list his/her qualifications?
* Is this person qualified to write this document?
*What type of organization provides the page? Is it:
Government:       .gov
Education:           .edu
Business:            .com
Organisation:      .org
*What country is the page from?

2. Purpose  
What is the purpose of the document? 
To:
* Inform
* Entertain
* Share information
*Advertise or sell a product or service (business/marketing)
* Influence views, beliefs 
* Personal enjoyment
 
3. Structural features
Identify some of the structural features of the web page eg
  • use of colour
  • font size and style
  • graphics
  • video or animation
  • tabs 
  • links

  4. Audience
  * Who is the audience?
  * What features have been included to appeal to this audience
  • Structural features
  • Language features
5. Objectivity of web documents
* How detailed is the information?
* What opinions (if any) are expressed by the author?
* Can the information be checked from other sources?

6. Currency of web documents
* When was it produced?
* When was it updated?
* How many dead links are there?
* Is the information up to date?
* How much advertising is there?


Check these sites out for veracity

Checking out the following sites are a useful (and fun) way for students to use the questions above to check out the veracity, reliability, usefulness and bias of a site.






http://www.moonmovie.com/moonmovie/default.asp

http://zapatopi.net/treeoctopus.html

http://www.rythospital.com/

http://zapatopi.net/afdb.html

http://www.umbachconsulting.com/miscellany/velcro.html

http://www.genochoice.com/

http://www.dhmo.org/

http://www.improb.com/airchives/classical/cat/cat.html (scroll down)

http://haggishunt.scotsman.com/


http://www.hetracil.com/

http://ding.net/bonsaikitten/

http://havidol.com/

http://www.modernplasztika.co.hu/audioful_eng.html

http://www.icrwhale.net/

http://savetherennets.com/

http://www.geoffmetcalf.com/bread.html

http://www.petroldirect.com/

http://www.sandman.com/telco.html